Regenexx Blog
By Chris Centeno, MD / December 3, 2019
I’ve become pretty used to the fads in regen med that I’ve witnessed for the last decade and a half. It seems like every year or two something gets hot and then eventually fizzles out and then it’s on to the next thing. Right now that hot item is exosome treatment. The funny thing is that if you’ve already used or had PRP, you have already experienced an exosome therapy. Let me explain.
Exosomes as Penicillin?
I’ve had physicians tell me that exosome treatment is the Penicillin of the 21st century. Most only understand what an exosome is at a basic level. For example, they generally know that an exosome is produced by a cell and that it can affect other cells (1). They kind of know that exosomes can carry different types of things like mRNA and growth factors (2), but that’s where their understanding stops. However, let’s learn more.
There are Hundreds of Different Types of Exosomes
If we stick with the Penicillin analogy, we know that this is an antibiotic. We also know that antibiotics are a type of drug and that there are thousands of different drugs which all have different effects on the body. Some can help certain diseases and some do nothing for other diseases. Exosomes are just the same. There are at least several hundred different types that can all do different things and these can be identified via flow cytometry (16). The problem right now is that nobody is clear on how to isolate specific exosomes that do specific things like repairing your cartilage or nerves.
In addition, not all exosomes are good. For example, in one study, two were identified that were associated with a higher mortality rate in ICU patients (10). In addition, there’s an evolving area of research that rare and deadly prions hitch a ride in exosomes (24).
PRP is an Exosome Treatment
The exosome treatment sales crowd is heavily focused on creating products mostly derived from birth tissues. However, what they forget is that just about every cell in your body produces exosomes and this even extends to non-cellular fragments like platelets. So is platelet-rich plasma (PRP) an exosome therapy?
We all know that platelets clot the blood and then release their growth factor contents via vesicles to promote local healing. However, as shown above, they also release exosomes just like cells. These begin as multivesicular bodies (MVBs) inside the platelet.
Platelets release hundreds of different types of exosomes (9,11,13,14,19, 21). In addition, these exosomes will survive bursting the platelet open to create platelet lysate, which in part works through exosomes (23). As with cells, what’s in the exosomes that are released depends on what the platelet senses in its local environment and when (25). For example, it was found that using a platelet-derived exosome treatment to heal wounds needs to be carefully timed to maximize results (6). This is obviously something normally handled by the platelet which detects what needs to be delivered and then releases that growth factor or exosome at the specific moment when it’s needed.
Exosomes released by platelets play a big role in blood vessel and cardiac disease protection and repair (3, 4,8,11,15) As a result, it makes sense that platelets release exosomes after exercise (7). Basically, acting to maintain and right-size the vasculature needed to support more physical activity.
Platelet-derived exosomes are also known to have key therapeutic effects. For example, platelet exosomes can cross the Blood-Brain Barrier and participate in new neuron growth (5). An exosome treatment derived from PRP can also heal diabetic skin wounds and even prevent cell death in osteonecrosis (a bone death disease) (17, 20).
In addition, the science behind platelets and exosomes is so robust that we even know what impacts their release. For example, the drug used to activate platelets determines the types of exosomes released (18). Also, different drugs taken by the patient can also change the payloads in the exosomes. For instance, aspirin reduced the total number of proteins in platelet released exosomes (22).
The upshot? PRP is an exosome treatment. The big difference is that platelets are intelligent machines that know which types of exosomes to release and when. You don’t get that when you just dump a bunch of isolated exosomes into an area and hope for the best.
Click for references:
regenexx.com
By Chris Centeno, MD / December 3, 2019
I’ve become pretty used to the fads in regen med that I’ve witnessed for the last decade and a half. It seems like every year or two something gets hot and then eventually fizzles out and then it’s on to the next thing. Right now that hot item is exosome treatment. The funny thing is that if you’ve already used or had PRP, you have already experienced an exosome therapy. Let me explain.
Exosomes as Penicillin?
I’ve had physicians tell me that exosome treatment is the Penicillin of the 21st century. Most only understand what an exosome is at a basic level. For example, they generally know that an exosome is produced by a cell and that it can affect other cells (1). They kind of know that exosomes can carry different types of things like mRNA and growth factors (2), but that’s where their understanding stops. However, let’s learn more.
There are Hundreds of Different Types of Exosomes
If we stick with the Penicillin analogy, we know that this is an antibiotic. We also know that antibiotics are a type of drug and that there are thousands of different drugs which all have different effects on the body. Some can help certain diseases and some do nothing for other diseases. Exosomes are just the same. There are at least several hundred different types that can all do different things and these can be identified via flow cytometry (16). The problem right now is that nobody is clear on how to isolate specific exosomes that do specific things like repairing your cartilage or nerves.
In addition, not all exosomes are good. For example, in one study, two were identified that were associated with a higher mortality rate in ICU patients (10). In addition, there’s an evolving area of research that rare and deadly prions hitch a ride in exosomes (24).
PRP is an Exosome Treatment
The exosome treatment sales crowd is heavily focused on creating products mostly derived from birth tissues. However, what they forget is that just about every cell in your body produces exosomes and this even extends to non-cellular fragments like platelets. So is platelet-rich plasma (PRP) an exosome therapy?
We all know that platelets clot the blood and then release their growth factor contents via vesicles to promote local healing. However, as shown above, they also release exosomes just like cells. These begin as multivesicular bodies (MVBs) inside the platelet.
Platelets release hundreds of different types of exosomes (9,11,13,14,19, 21). In addition, these exosomes will survive bursting the platelet open to create platelet lysate, which in part works through exosomes (23). As with cells, what’s in the exosomes that are released depends on what the platelet senses in its local environment and when (25). For example, it was found that using a platelet-derived exosome treatment to heal wounds needs to be carefully timed to maximize results (6). This is obviously something normally handled by the platelet which detects what needs to be delivered and then releases that growth factor or exosome at the specific moment when it’s needed.
Exosomes released by platelets play a big role in blood vessel and cardiac disease protection and repair (3, 4,8,11,15) As a result, it makes sense that platelets release exosomes after exercise (7). Basically, acting to maintain and right-size the vasculature needed to support more physical activity.
Platelet-derived exosomes are also known to have key therapeutic effects. For example, platelet exosomes can cross the Blood-Brain Barrier and participate in new neuron growth (5). An exosome treatment derived from PRP can also heal diabetic skin wounds and even prevent cell death in osteonecrosis (a bone death disease) (17, 20).
In addition, the science behind platelets and exosomes is so robust that we even know what impacts their release. For example, the drug used to activate platelets determines the types of exosomes released (18). Also, different drugs taken by the patient can also change the payloads in the exosomes. For instance, aspirin reduced the total number of proteins in platelet released exosomes (22).
The upshot? PRP is an exosome treatment. The big difference is that platelets are intelligent machines that know which types of exosomes to release and when. You don’t get that when you just dump a bunch of isolated exosomes into an area and hope for the best.
Click for references:
Is PRP an Exosome Treatment?
A phjysician regen med expert reviews the science behind exosome treatment and also shows how Platelet-Rich Plasma (PRP) releases exsosomes.
regenexx.com